Without getting into the debate as well, BOV were designed for standard shift cars. It helps keep the turbo spinning while shifting gears. So when you release the throttle and it closes, pressure is released so that the pressure does not try to go back through the turbo, slowing it down. My Gensis has one and it was originally designed to recirculate the pressure back into the intake pipe. I have replaced it with one that vents out into the atmosphere. The only reason I can figure it was originally a recirculated system was to make it so there was no noise. Now do we need one for our TB's? Who cares! I will be putting one on my because I just dropped $2000+ on a turbo and I will do what I can to extend the life of my turbo.