hum
The first page you posted had the gaskets at the bottom; I didn't know the 7.2" was the same as the 8.5". I know they measure the covers really weird. I've had this problem before. Do you have a local auto parts store that may have both gaskets on the shelf? Maybe looking at the gaskets in person would help. Also you could look for numbers on the rear end. I believe they were on the axle housing, driver’s side if I remember correctly, check both sides. If you find some numbers you could call the dealer and give them what you find, they should be able to help you. A different choice would be to call Randy's ring and pinion here on the west cost, they should be open and could probably help you figure it out. Hope this help... -Gabe